|
|
| Assessment of Early Childhood Education Training
on Practices in the Liberian Classroom More than a year after the last Liberian Education Assistance Project (LEAP) in-service workshop, dozens of primary school teachers and principals are practicing what they learned at the sessions, building on and adapting those methods and most importantly, teaching others how to plan and implement developmentally appropriate lessons, using locally available materials for a nurturing classroom environment. Public school teachers were committed to professional development, though they were not paid for 11 months (they received their January 2002 checks in November). In November 2002, two U.S. trainers visited 42 schools of LEAP-trained teachers in five counties, interviewed 26 LEAP-trained teachers at length, held teacher meetings in two counties and came away with some recommendations for how to build on this foundation for good early childhood education. Background In three annual workshops, 127 teachers and principals were trained, usually in school teams. They came from six counties in central Liberia: Bong, Nimba, Margibi, Bassa, Bomi and Montserrado. Eight participants had been trained to be co-trainers, working alongside their U.S. counterparts to teach other adults what they had absorbed from the workshops and their own experiences implementing new teaching techniques in the classroom. After 2001, the "co-trainers" had been convening meetings semi-annually by county to network the "LEAP-trained" teachers and enable them to share classroom practices that worked best. The July 2002 workshop would have allowed the co-trainers a significant role in teaching the workshop. It was designed to strengthen the skills of the corps of co-trainers toward a five-year goal of having the workshops run entirely by a Liberian team of trainers. In April 2002, dissident forces overran the area and the campus of Cuttington College, where the workshops were held. The subsequent looting and displacement of the population made it impossible to ask teachers to travel either from the United States or from neighboring counties. Throughout the crisis, the U.S. LEAP planners were able to communicate with training leaders through e-mail from the capital city, Monrovia, and encourage the teachers who could to continue meeting and supporting each other. In the fall of 2002, security conditions had improved enough to consider sending an assessment team to gauge the longer-term impact of the short-term in-service intervention on practices in Liberian classrooms. In conducting school observations, the visiting teachers sought to determine whether trained LEAP teachers and principals, some of them trained three years previously, were still using the concepts and methods they learned in the workshops. The teachers also planned to give support where possible to the teachers using the new practices, further train the trainers, gain Ministry of Education acceptance of the principles of the LEAP training program and help the Liberian training team formalize their teamwork by forming a non-governmental organization (NGO) to maintain and expand the LEAP teacher development program. The following are the findings of Dr. Joan Safran Hamilton and LEAP Administrator Stephanie Vickers in a three-week visit during November of 2002. Stephanie Vickers filed the following report.
A significant amount of time was spent working on establishing a local educational NGO, to be called LET (LEAP Extension Team), which would formalize the work of the co-trainers in coaching their fellow teachers and sustaining the networking started by the workshops. We were accompanied on the three-week mission by Ernest Emmanual Shaw, I, a local cleric and elementary school principal from Johnsonville (rural Montserrado County) who has served as the co-administrator of the LEAP project since 2000 and will serve as Registrar for LET. I will share a sample of the conditions we found in 42 primary schools during the extended Liberian emergency and the findings of a personal survey of 26 of the teachers who participated in LEAP. The findings of our school visits and teacher surveys show the need for ongoing teacher-training and professional support in Liberia and the potential for long-term partnerships with this network of teachers. Our recommendations for more training and other teacher supports are based on these findings. School Observations Teachers, many whom had years of experience before the training, said that after their LEAP training, they observed that students are talking more about lessons and raising their hands more to contribute. One school set up an incentive program to reward students who do well. Parents thanked the teachers at this school for what they are doing now with their children. The principal thinks more children are attending school since the training he and his teacher received. This was a common belief among teachers and principals interviewed, that trained teachers are attracting more students to their classrooms. Some of the teachers reported feeling that teaching is easier with new ideas that work (junk box, use of local materials, less note taking, more hands-on teaching and more singing throughout the day and in all subject areas). Some teachers said that teaching was more fun and that they liked teaching more. Classroom confidence was apparent in many of the teachers we observed. LEAP techniques have made it easier for one teacher to get in touch with his students. Another change one teacher has seen is that in the past some of his students were passive and stubborn but they are more responsive now. So both teachers and students have changed and both groups appear to like that. In three of the counties affected by the fighting last spring (Bong, Margibi and Nimba), some younger students had not returned to school because parents are worried about their children's safety. Nevertheless, in half the schools visited, classes were full because parents wanted their children in classrooms with trained teachers. Nursery and ABC classes tend to be larger, ranging between 20 and 110. Money is scarce generally in Liberia and schools were still charging
fees when we visited. Even in schools that do not charge fees, schools
require students to wear uniforms and buy books. This is probably the
biggest obstacle to children attending classes. Bai Rogers, a food security official for Concern Worldwide Liberia, told the visiting teachers that an estimated 60 percent of Liberian children in rural areas are not in school. Many of those who come to school in rural areas walk more than an hour to get there. Teachers make their own resources, a practice that was emphasized at the LEAP workshops. Homemade materials were widely evident in the schools we visited. For example, many had made posters for their walls on various subjects to make up for the lack of books. They had collected local materials for their "junk boxes," a LEAP practice that encourages children's curiosity and imagination. One teacher had collected discarded candy wrappers and told children to pretend they were Liberian five-dollar bills. She then used them to teach students to work with money and count by fives. Science teachers collected water bottles to use as rain gauges or containers for plant experiments. Teachers taught students to make models of cars, ships and buildings, with some amazingly imaginative results. Many LEAP teachers in the counties affected by the April fighting, Bong, Margibi and Bomi, lost their manuals and other materials in the looting that followed and requested replacements. The said that they had come to rely on the manuals as reminders of what they had been taught and how it fit together. These materials were intended to help teachers plan lessons according to the Liberian curriculum. They are the only such material support most teachers had ever been given. One workshop co-trainer fled Bomi Hills, where the fighting was intense, with only one bag, but her teacher manuals were in it. She began a new school in Monrovia and trained all her teachers in LEAP techniques. The results of our surveys lead us to estimate that this training of colleagues has impacted a minimum of approximately 22,400 students in rural Liberia
Theo Frankyu, an elementary school principal and LEAP co-trainer, is in regular contact with the LEAP administrator, Ernest Shaw. He will be the co-administrator of the new teacher NGO. Highly motivated and respected in his community, he provided us with the best example of LEAP objectives in practice by county. He has held several county-wide teacher meetings over the last year in Buchanan. The Grand Bassa LEAP-trained teachers and others they have trained meet monthly to work and share ideas and then may come together every couple of weeks for other work. LEAP funds were used initially to support the county meetings. Theo reported that even in the absence of funding, the teachers brought food to share and even pitched in a few dollars to pay for supplies. The effect on teaching was obvious in the nine schools we observed. It should be noted that they all had prior notice of our visit, something that was not possible in other counties. In the nine Buchanan schools, we took photographs, met with teachers, interviewed some and saw many children working in their classrooms. We were surprised with the number of LEAP-trained techniques in action. At one school, a LEAP participant had made a dramatic change in her teaching and attitude about being a teacher since the workshop she attended in 2001. She was using techniques in her ABC (Nursery) classroom that she learned in the July workshop and extended them to create additional developmentally appropriate activities with her students. This teacher, who had since been named head teacher in her kindergarten school, told us that she no longer was shy and had gained more confidence in the classroom. She had been given the responsibility for training other teachers at her school. This teacher also felt that more students are coming to her school since her LEAP training. At another school, Central Buchanan Elementary School Soldiers Barracks, teachers had prepared a proposal for Friends of Liberia to assist the community in rebuilding its school. Teachers and students were gathering in a working army barracks and parents were reluctant to send their children to school there. The school houses eight teachers and 180 children in grades one through six. In spite of the dim lighting and absence of resources, the LEAP trained teachers were trying to practice LEAP techniques learned in July 2001 and students' attendance was high. One of the teachers showed us how he had used local materials to make his own balance scale. He had also trained other teachers in his school. Co-trainer Frankyu has also trained other teachers in Buchanan with LEAP techniques and includes them in his frequent forums and meetings. He has trained his ABC/Kindergarten teacher and with the community's assistance built an ABC classroom for her students. This classroom is used as a model for his county teacher meetings. Margibi County In Kakata, we visited a LEAP school that had been moved to an old market site after the April fighting and subsequent looting had damaged the school building. The market schoolrooms were poorly lit, had dirt floors were very crowded and poorly ventilated. Unfortunately we did not find a LEAP teacher still working there. We were told that most of the teachers had left after the problems in April and the one trained LEAP teacher was promoted to Registrar and is no longer in the classroom. It was apparent that no training had occurred because we did not see any signs of developmentally appropriate practices in any of the several classrooms we visited. We found challenging conditions at other schools in the Kakata area as well. In some schools, LEAP-trained teachers had left for Monrovia or had transferred to private schools in the area, where the pay is more consistent. At John Joseph Elementary-Junior High, parents came together to help fix up the school after it was significantly damaged in the fighting. The LEAP-trained principal had fled, but the LEAP-trained teacher had returned to the school, which the new principal appreciated a lot.
Bong County Sugar Hill Community School, a K-12 school that had been largely assisted by Friends of Liberia and other outside groups because of its superior organization, was badly damaged by soldiers and looters. It may have been a target because of the material assets the school had collected. Its exemplary vocational program, with its tools, sewing machines, musical instruments and baking utensils, was particularly attractive to looters, many of whom may have been locals. Since the incursions, the vocational school has been suspended and general enrollment is down. Students are slowly returning, but many of the teachers who fled have yet to return. The trained teachers who have remained are trying hard to continue their LEAP techniques and have shared their materials and skills with many of the others on the Sugar Hill staff. Many of the teachers are starting over and asking students and parents to help with teaching materials. For instance, students were asked to bring big and small things for a lesson on size in the ABC classroom. The LEAP-trained principal at Sugar Hill told us how he has used LEAP ideas with upper grade classes and feels the age-appropriate techniques can be adapted for any class. Nimba County The students there also built a second eco stove for the school. This is an idea taught at LEAP workshops in the science and environmental track. Schools are encouraged to demonstrate the fuel conservation inherent in building a mud stove that restricts the amount of oxygen that gets to the fire. Unfortunately, schools have no longer have food provided by the international aid organizations, so the lesson is less central in community life. The eco-stove, demonstrated at LEAP workshops, is easily replicable technology whose principal material is mud. Several schools built stoves and served as a model of the technique for the community. We also visited schools in the Ganta area and found some LEAP teachers still practicing LEAP techniques and sharing with other staff. One teacher had transferred to another school after her second year of LEAP work and introduced LEAP ideas to her new school. Her principal appreciates the difference in her teaching and asked to be invited to the next July workshop. One teacher who had left a government school to work at a private school saw us on the road and came after us to visit her at her new school where she was working with grades one and two and shared some of the songs that she had taught them already. School had only been in session about a month. At another school in Nimba County, Dingamo, one teacher provided a dark example of the risk of change. She chose to leave her school after her LEAP training, when the principal suspended her pay, saying that fees and materials she received from the LEAP workshop were her salary. Her colleague who went to the same July 2001 workshop has trained another teacher in some of the techniques. He apparently was not subject to the same LEAP penalty. Montserrado County The teacher and co-trainer, Baindu Taylor, who fled to Monrovia from Bomi Hills, has set up a new school, Restore Future Elementary School, of approximately 70 students in grades one through four and has trained her staff of six with LEAP techniques. She told us, "I don't have to buy things. I can use local materials. The ideas for my lessons come easier. I used to have students take notes but now I let the kids be more involved in the lessons. The students are more relaxed and they like taking less notes." Another example in Monrovia was at Cathedral School. A non-LEAP principal praised LEAP's influence when we visited. He said his LEAP-trained teacher is used to motivating others as she relates her lesson plans, presentation and evaluation. He said, "She is a standard of reference for other teachers." Ernest Shaw, the LEAP administrator, was initially sponsored by Friends of Liberia to attend the workshop as a principal because his school, in the rural eastern part of the county, had been rebuilt by another FOL project. His leadership ability and experience working with the sponsoring group had made him a natural for administrator. Another of his teachers accompanied him to the first workshop and since then, he has taught all his teachers, regardless of grade in age-appropriate teaching and planning. Consequently, Ernest Shaw's school has been practicing LEAP techniques since 1999. The first group of primary grade students to benefit from LEAP-trained teaching is now in the 5th grade. Twenty-four are still in school, many of them girls, Shaw points out. He expects the real test of this difference will be in the 6th grade, when this class takes its first national exam. He and his teachers expect the results of teacher training to show in those results. Teachers Training Other Teachers We were told repeatedly about the workshops that LEAP teachers and principals held for other teachers in their own schools and for other teachers in their towns. In the previous school year, ten LEAP teachers and principals in the five relevant counties conducted 23 workshops. Twenty-one of the teachers interviewed said that they had shared ideas in their schools and answered questions and shared practices with colleagues. The LEAP co-trainers had planned to hold two forums in each of their counties for teachers in the course of the school year. At the first meetings, teachers came together to share experiences, ideas and techniques. But due to the disruption and poor security situation after the April fighting, the second workshop was not held except in Grand Bassa, where there was no fighting. We heard many times from teachers in the other counties that they missed the opportunity to work together. The frequent meetings of LEAP trained teachers that were conducted by Theo Frankyu in Buchanan provide a model of how the plan might work in other counties. The teachers obviously benefit from the retraining and support for their teaching. We saw many LEAP practices in the classrooms of other counties, but unfortunately there are still many teachers who have had difficulty changing their teaching style and carrying out what we had taught them at the workshops. Some were attempting to teach content they did not fully understand. Some of the teachers were not as strong in their teaching because they had not had any training since year one of the workshops (1999). We found that the LEAP training improved each year that it was held, so that each year we were able to provide better resources and information for later participants. Other teachers did not have the support of a trained principal; some were in schools that had been disrupted by fighting and had supplies looted. Some teachers have left the profession and some, maybe 10 percent, have moved to private schools, where pay is more consistent. Several teachers who moved to private schools shared LEAP ideas with teachers in their new schools. In one such school, a new ABC class is being planned for the first time because the teacher is so enthusiastic about using LEAP techniques with the little children. One LEAP principal traveled to Monrovia to look for his nursery grade teacher who had fled in the fighting to ask her to return to his Bong County school. During our visits to schools of LEAP participants, we found that the teachers and principals who were trained in 2001 were stronger teachers and better understood the concepts of early childhood and were teaching more developmentally appropriately and hands-on teaching. Partly this can be attributed to the increased experience of the trainers, who had been doing it for three years and better curriculum development by the trainers. We also saw evidence that the county teacher forums during the school year were supporting the learning from the July workshops. These semi-annual forums began after the July 2001 workshops. The example of Buchanan, where these meetings happened regularly, showed the effects in the teaching.
At our forum at Phebe Hospital Compound in Bong County, Joan and I took over more of the training to respond to the teachers' request for phonics support and more teaching ideas. We also responded to the needs of upper grade teachers (2-7th grade) in attendance, many of them principals who had been to the workshops with their primary grade teachers, with a discussion on how to modify LEAP early childhood practices and hands-on principles for older students. For example, we led a discussion on how to teach 5th-grade English. Over 55 participants and visitors, including Deputy Minister Peter Ben and the Archdiocese Representative for Catholic Schools in Bong County, attended the forum. All of the LEAP co-trainers met at the conclusion of the Phoebe forum. They set up a schedule of where they would meet to plan for county forums. Their next meeting is Jan. 17. County forums will be held at different times so the co-trainers can travel to assist each other if their schedules permit. Each co-trainer was given some funds to use for travel in his/her county and town. Co-trainers were also paid an additional fee to mentor their colleagues. We specifically suggested visiting LEAP participants who had not had the latest training or had not attended forums. These co-trainers will be the nucleus of the LET teacher NGO. They will largely plan and implement the next workshop.
Most teachers received their January 2002, paycheck in November. In Nimbi County, teachers have not even received their January check. In many instances, when the check is delivered to the school or county office, a fee or surcharge of 8 percent had been taken out of the 800-Liberian-dollar payment. Basically many of the government teachers are volunteers. They also know how difficult it is for students to pay fees and make arrangements with students to attend and pay when they can. Many teachers in Bomb, Bong and Upper Margi had to flee with just the
clothes on their backs. Their classrooms were looted and we heard many
complaints that their LEAP manuals and supplies had been taken. Some teachers
have to daily take their pictures and supplies to school and put them
up and take them down. If they left them, they would be taken or if another
teacher used the room in the afternoon, the things would be taken down.
Many schools had two or three sessions per day. Many of the teachers had
worked to rebuild their junk boxes, wall hangings and teaching materials It is hard to predict what the effect on schools will be when the Liberian government's mandate for free universal education goes into effect in the next school year. Ministry of Education Dr. Hamilton explained the need for Liberian educators to understand the concepts of early childhood education and developmentally appropriate teaching. We reminded the Minister that we had left LEAP training manuals with the Ministry in July 2001. The Minister asked to see the Early Childhood Manual, so we left a copy to be copied for others in her ministry to read before we returned at the end of our trip. On our return, she suggested that it might be possible to use the manual for training early childhood educators next year. She asked Dr. Hamilton to add a section on "Getting to Know Liberia" and asked whether Friends of Liberia could publish 5,000 manuals. She also suggested we meet with UNICEF to tie in other areas in the early childhood manual dealing with life skills. We stressed that use of the manuals would have to be in conjunction with training in order to be effective. She agreed that LEAP-trained teachers should be a part of the training of other Liberian teachers. This acknowledgment is a step closer to getting certification and national recognition for our LEAP-trained teachers. I was asked by Deputy Minister Ben to write up a rational for certification to present to the MOE. Minister Kandakai said, "Friends of Liberia is helping the education sector in Liberia to reach into the classroom to make an impact on the quality of instruction which is a very neglected area because most polices' interventions do not filter down to the classroom." Paying for and training teachers to meet the needs of the Education Act for Compulsory Education in 2002 is a huge concern. Funding is supposed to come from the government and UNICEF. The Minister was impressed at the number of LEAP teachers who were women and wants to include them in the international organization, Forum for African Women Educationalists (FAWE), which is in thirty-three African countries. Its goal is to support girls' education. She suggested that the new local NGO, LET, be involved in FAWE's school of excellence and to help train other Liberian teachers Finally, the Minister said she supports LEAP's formation of the local organization LET. With her support, we pursued the incorporation of a local teacher NGO. A Monrovia lawyer filed papers with the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and a letter from the Ministry of Education was sent to the Minister of Planning. As of the end of December, LET Administrator Ernest Shaw reported that he had not been given an audience with the Minister in charge of incorporation.
Changing the conditions in which teachers teach is a role for government and large international NGOs. It will take more than a mandate to improve the education of children. An important part of the solution will be more training and support for those who are in the classrooms. LEAP will offer a workshop in July 2003 that aims to strengthen the skills of the LEAP co-trainers who have formed LET. We believe this indigenous NGO will lead to more teachers and schools to the successful teaching of young children. It is not easy to travel and work in Liberia, but the short-term intervention program of Friends of Liberia, LEAP, is making a difference. In spite of the difficult conditions and lack of government support for schools, many teachers and principals are doing great things for the children of Liberia and we need to continue our support of rural education. Toward that end, we make the following recommendations: · The co-trainers of the LET organization should largely plan
LEAP's 2003 workshop. The role of U.S. trainers will be to train these
trainers to work with other adults. |
| Friends of Liberia Home | LEAP Assessment Photo Gallery |